User Adoption Strategy: The Complete Guide to Turning New Users Into Active Customers

You can acquire thousands of users and still have an adoption problem.

Sign-ups, downloads, and free trials tell you that people entered your product. They don’t tell you whether users understood its value, reached the right outcome, or made the product part of their workflow.

Acquisition gets users through the door. User adoption determines whether they stay.

Most guides answer a narrow question: What strategies can I use to increase user adoption? This guide answers a bigger one: Why aren’t users adopting your product, how do you identify the exact problem, and what should you do at each stage to turn new users into active, retained, and engaged customers?

Here’s what this guide covers:

  • What user adoption means and how it differs from acquisition, activation, and retention
  • Why adoption fails (and how to diagnose the real problem)
  • The user adoption lifecycle and funnel
  • A complete framework for building an adoption strategy
  • 15 actionable strategies that work
  • Metrics, formulas, and a diagnostic decision table
  • Examples, common mistakes, and a 30-day implementation plan

What Is User Adoption?

User adoption is the process of getting users to understand, use, and consistently derive value from a product, service, feature, or technology. Successful adoption goes beyond signup or first use; it occurs when the product becomes part of the user’s regular workflow .

Adoption isn’t simply:

  • Logging in
  • Downloading an app
  • Signing up
  • Clicking a feature once

True adoption occurs when the product becomes useful enough to become part of the user’s regular behavior.

User Adoption vs Product Adoption

While often used interchangeably, there’s a subtle distinction. User adoption focuses on the behavioral journey of individual users or teams—their actions, habits, and value realization. Product adoption takes a broader business perspective, measuring overall uptake of a product or feature across the user base .

Both perspectives matter. You need to understand individual user behavior to design interventions, but you also need aggregate product metrics to assess strategy effectiveness.

User Adoption vs User Acquisition

Acquisition is the act of getting someone to sign up or download. Adoption is what happens after. A high acquisition rate with low adoption is like filling a leaky bucket—you’re spending resources to bring people in, but they’re not staying.

User Adoption vs User Activation

Activation is the moment a user completes a meaningful first action that indicates they’ve started receiving value. Adoption is the longer process of turning that initial activation into a sustained habit .

Activation is a milestone. Adoption is a journey.

User Adoption vs User Engagement

Engagement measures how often and how deeply users interact with your product. Adoption is about whether they integrate it into their workflow. A user can be highly engaged for a week and then churn. Adoption implies stickiness.

User Adoption vs Customer Retention

Retention measures whether users stay. Adoption explains why they stay—because they’ve found repeated value and formed habits. Strong adoption drives retention; retention without adoption is fragile .


Why Is User Adoption Important?

User adoption isn’t just a nice metric to track. It’s the engine that drives sustainable growth.

Consider this logical chain:

Acquisition → Activation → Adoption → Engagement → Retention → Expansion → Advocacy

Each stage depends on the previous one. If adoption is weak, everything downstream suffers.

Poor adoption affects:

  • Churn: Users who don’t adopt leave. Users who adopt stay .
  • Customer lifetime value: Adopted users generate more revenue over a longer period.
  • Support costs: Users who understand the product need less help.
  • Product ROI: A product that isn’t used doesn’t deliver returns.
  • Expansion revenue: Users who adopt core features are more likely to upgrade.
  • Customer satisfaction: Value realization drives satisfaction.
  • Referrals: Adopted users become advocates.

What Happens When User Adoption Is Low?

Here’s a realistic scenario:

  • 10,000 users sign up
  • 6,000 activate (complete first meaningful action)
  • 2,000 reach meaningful value
  • 700 become regular users

The headline number—10,000 signups—looks great. The reality is that only 7% of users became regulars. Without measuring adoption, you’d never know where the breakdown occurred.


How Does the User Adoption Process Work?

Understanding the adoption lifecycle is essential for designing interventions at the right moments.

The User Adoption Lifecycle

Stage 1: Awareness
The user discovers the product. This happens through marketing, word-of-mouth, or search.

Stage 2: Signup / Acquisition
The user enters the product ecosystem. They create an account or start a trial.

Stage 3: Activation
The user completes the first meaningful action. This is a leading indicator of future adoption .

Stage 4: First Value
The user experiences the product’s core benefit. They accomplish something they couldn’t easily do before.

Stage 5: Habit Formation
The user starts returning regularly. The product begins to fit into their routine.

Stage 6: Feature Adoption
The user discovers additional valuable capabilities. Depth of usage increases.

Stage 7: Retention
The product becomes part of the user’s workflow. They would miss it if it disappeared.

Stage 8: Expansion
The user adopts more features, seats, or use cases.

Stage 9: Advocacy
The user recommends the product to others .

This lifecycle is more useful than a simple list of onboarding tips because it clarifies what needs to happen at each stage.


The User Adoption Funnel

Think of adoption as a funnel:

Acquired → Activated → Value Achieved → Engaged → Adopted → Retained → Expanded → Advocate

For each stage, you need to understand:

StageUser BehaviorBusiness ObjectiveCommon FrictionMetric to TrackRecommended Intervention
AcquiredSigns upGet user into productComplex signupSignup rateSimplify registration
ActivatedCompletes first actionReach “aha moment”Unclear next stepsActivation rateOnboarding checklist
Value AchievedExperiences core benefitDemonstrate ROITime-to-value too longTime to valueRemove friction
EngagedReturns regularlyBuild habitWeak recurring valueDAU/WAUContextual guidance
AdoptedUses core features consistentlyDeepen usageFeature discoverabilityFeature adoption rateIn-app announcements
RetainedStays long-termReduce churnUnmet needsRetention rateFeedback loops
ExpandedUses more features/seatsGrow revenueUnclear expansion pathExpansion rateUpgrade prompts
AdvocateRefers othersOrganic growthNo referral incentiveNPS, referralsReferral program

This funnel can become your diagnostic tool. When adoption is low, identify which stage is breaking down.


Why Do Users Fail to Adopt a Product?

Most guides jump straight to strategies. But you can’t fix a problem you haven’t diagnosed.

Here are the most common reasons users fail to adopt:

Users Don’t Understand the Value

If users can’t quickly grasp why the product matters, they won’t invest time exploring it . This is a messaging problem, not a product problem.

Time-to-Value Is Too Long

Some products require significant configuration before any payoff appears. Users abandon before they see results .

Onboarding Is Complicated

A disjointed or overly complex onboarding process delays time-to-value and increases drop-off .

Too Many Features Create Cognitive Overload

Showing everything at once overwhelms users. They disengage before forming a habit.

Users Don’t Know What to Do Next

Without clear guidance, users stall. They complete initial setup but don’t know how to progress.

The Product Doesn’t Match the User’s Workflow

If the product requires users to change how they work without clear benefit, they’ll revert to old habits.

Poor UX Creates Friction

Technical glitches, confusing navigation, and slow performance all create friction that compounds over time .

Users Aren’t Properly Educated

Help content often lives in documentation, far from where users actually struggle. Self-education at the wrong moment fails .

Product Messaging Doesn’t Match User Expectations

If marketing promises one thing and the product delivers another, trust erodes. Adoption stalls.

Important Features Remain Undiscovered

Features buried in menus or introduced without context go unnoticed .

There Is No Personalized Experience

Generic onboarding assumes all users have the same goals. They don’t .

Teams Measure Logins Instead of Meaningful Adoption

Vanity metrics create false confidence. Logins don’t equal value .

Feedback Isn’t Converted Into Product Improvements

Collecting feedback without acting on it signals to users that their input doesn’t matter.


How to Build a User Adoption Strategy

A user adoption strategy is a plan that helps users move from awareness to advocacy. It’s not a one-time campaign; it’s an ongoing system.

Here’s a framework that covers the entire journey.

The 8-Step User Adoption Framework

Understand → Diagnose → Activate → Educate → Engage → Expand → Measure → Optimize

Step 1: Define Your Ideal Users

Create user personas that include:

  • Roles and responsibilities
  • Use cases
  • Jobs-to-be-done
  • Pain points
  • Technical ability
  • Goals

Different segments need different approaches. A solo founder shouldn’t see the same onboarding as an enterprise team .

Step 2: Identify the User’s Desired Outcome

Ask: What does the user actually want to accomplish?

Don’t build the strategy around features. Build it around outcomes. A project management tool doesn’t sell “kanban boards”—it sells “shipping projects on time.”

Step 3: Define the Activation Event

What action indicates that the user has started receiving value?

Examples:

  • Creating a project
  • Sending a first campaign
  • Inviting a team member
  • Completing a first transaction
  • Generating a first report

The activation event should correlate with retention. Users who activate are significantly more likely to stay .

Step 4: Identify the “Aha Moment”

The “aha moment” is when the user feels the value, not just completes an action. The difference:

  • First action: User clicks “Create Project”
  • First value: User sees their team collaborating on a project and realizes this is faster than email

Design onboarding to drive users to the aha moment as quickly as possible.

Step 5: Map the User Journey

Map the path from entry to expansion:

Entry → Onboarding → Activation → Value → Habit → Expansion

Identify every step, every decision point, and every potential friction.

Step 6: Identify Adoption Friction

Use multiple data sources:

  • Product analytics: Where do users drop off?
  • Customer interviews: What frustrates them?
  • Surveys: What do they wish was easier?
  • Support tickets: What questions keep coming up?
  • Session recordings: Where do users hesitate or rage-click?
  • Usability testing: What breaks in real scenarios?

Step 7: Create Targeted Interventions

Match the problem with the appropriate solution. A discoverability problem needs in-app guidance. A value problem needs better onboarding. A workflow problem needs product changes.

Step 8: Measure → Test → Optimize

Adoption is not a one-time project. Track metrics, run experiments, and iterate continuously.


15 User Adoption Strategies That Actually Work

These strategies are organized by the stage they address, not just listed randomly.

Strategy 1: Reduce Time to Value

Identify the first-value event and eliminate every unnecessary step before it. Simplify setup, provide templates, and pre-populate data where possible.

Strategy 2: Personalize Onboarding

Segment users by role, use case, company size, experience, and goals. Even light segmentation dramatically improves relevance .

Strategy 3: Build Outcome-Based Onboarding

Don’t teach every feature. Teach users how to achieve their desired outcome. Onboarding should be about “how to launch your first campaign,” not “here’s the campaign builder interface.”

Strategy 4: Use Interactive Product Walkthroughs

Interactive walkthroughs that have users take actions are more effective than passive product tours. Users who complete interactive walkthroughs are far more likely to activate .

Strategy 5: Create Onboarding Checklists

Give users a clear path. Progress bars and checklists increase completion rates because seeing progress motivates users to finish .

Strategy 6: Use Contextual In-App Guidance

Help users when they need help. Tooltips, modals, and highlights triggered by specific user events are more effective than generic documentation .

Strategy 7: Create Progressive Onboarding

Don’t show everything on day one. Introduce complexity as users become more sophisticated. Start with the essentials and reveal advanced features as users gain familiarity .

Strategy 8: Make Important Features Discoverable

Use contextual prompts, feature announcements, tooltips, empty states, and contextual CTAs. Don’t assume users will explore on their own.

Strategy 9: Use Behavioral Segmentation

Create segments based on actual product behavior:

  • Signed up but inactive → Activation campaign
  • Activated but low usage → Engagement campaign
  • Power user → Expansion campaign

Strategy 10: Learn from Power Users

Identify common actions, workflows, feature combinations, and frequency patterns among your most successful users. Turn these behaviors into onboarding paths for new users.

Strategy 11: Build a Continuous Education System

Include a knowledge base, tutorials, webinars, videos, email education, product tips, and templates. Education shouldn’t end after onboarding .

Strategy 12: Use Customer Feedback Loops

Collect feedback at critical moments—after onboarding, after first value, after a support interaction. Act on it visibly.

Strategy 13: Improve Feature Adoption

Don’t assume launching a feature means users will discover it. Create a process:

Feature Launch → Awareness → Education → First Use → Repeated Use → Adoption

Strategy 14: Re-Engage Inactive Users

Segment inactive users based on why they stopped. A user who never activated needs different messaging than a user who was active for months and then stopped.

Strategy 15: Run Adoption Experiments

Test onboarding length, CTA copy, product tours, messaging, personalization, email timing, and feature prompts. Small improvements compound.


How to Measure User Adoption

Competitors often list metrics without explaining how to use them. This section goes further.

The 4 Dimensions of User Adoption

1. Breadth
How many users are adopting?

2. Depth
How much of the product are they using?

3. Frequency
How often are they using it?

4. Duration
How long do they continue using it?

These four dimensions provide a complete picture. High breadth with low depth means many users are barely engaging. High depth with low frequency means users go deep occasionally but don’t form habits.


12 User Adoption Metrics to Track

1. User Adoption Rate

Formula: (Adopted Users ÷ Eligible Users) × 100 

Why it matters: The headline metric for adoption.

When to use it: To assess overall adoption health and track progress over time.

2. Activation Rate

Formula: (Users Who Complete Activation Event ÷ Total New Users) × 100

Why it matters: Predicts future retention. Activated users are far more likely to stay.

When to use it: To evaluate onboarding effectiveness.

3. Time to Value

Formula: Timestamp of First Value − Timestamp of Signup 

Why it matters: Shorter time to value correlates with higher adoption.

When to use it: To identify friction in the early journey.

4. Feature Adoption Rate

Formula: (Users Using Feature ÷ Total Users) × 100 

Why it matters: Reveals which features drive retention and which are ignored.

When to use it: To prioritize guidance and roadmap decisions.

5. Onboarding Completion Rate

Formula: (Users Who Complete Onboarding ÷ Total Users Who Start Onboarding) × 100

Why it matters: Indicates onboarding friction.

When to use it: To diagnose drop-off points in the onboarding flow.

6. DAU / WAU / MAU

Formula: Count of unique active users in a day/week/month

Why it matters: Measures engagement frequency.

When to use it: To track habit formation.

7. Stickiness

Formula: DAU ÷ MAU

Why it matters: Measures how often active users return. A higher ratio indicates stronger habit formation .

When to use it: To assess product stickiness.

8. Product Engagement Rate

Formula: Pendo’s PES = (Adoption + Stickiness + Growth) ÷ 3 

Why it matters: A composite score that provides a single view of engagement health.

When to use it: For executive dashboards and trend analysis.

9. User Retention Rate

Formula: ((Users at End − New Users) ÷ Users at Start) × 100 

Why it matters: Measures whether users stay.

When to use it: To evaluate long-term adoption success.

10. Churn Rate

Formula: (Customers Lost ÷ Customers at Start) × 100 

Why it matters: The inverse of retention. High churn signals adoption failure.

When to use it: To identify at-risk segments.

11. Expansion / Upsell Rate

Formula: (Revenue from Expansion ÷ Total Revenue) × 100

Why it matters: Adopted users expand. It’s a leading indicator of adoption depth.

When to use it: To measure post-adoption revenue impact.

12. Customer Lifetime Value

Formula: (Average Purchase Value × Average Purchase Frequency) × Average Customer Lifespan 

Why it matters: Adoption drives CLV. Tracking CLV by adoption cohort reveals the financial impact of adoption improvements.

When to use it: To justify adoption investments.


How to Calculate User Adoption Rate

If 5,000 users are eligible and 2,000 complete the defined adoption action:

2,000 ÷ 5,000 × 100 = 40% adoption rate

There is no universal “good” adoption rate. The definition of adoption differs by product, audience, use case, and timeframe. A B2B enterprise tool might define adoption as “weekly active usage by at least 3 team members.” A consumer app might define it as “returning within 7 days.”

What matters is consistency: define your adoption event, measure it consistently, and track improvement over time.


How to Improve User Adoption Based on Your Funnel

Use this diagnostic table to identify what to fix first:

ProblemLikely CauseWhat to Test
High signup, low activationPoor onboardingSimplify first-use flow
High activation, low retentionWeak recurring valueImprove core workflow
Low feature adoptionPoor discoverabilityContextual prompts
High onboarding completion, low usageOnboarding teaches instead of delivering valueOutcome-based onboarding
High usage, high churnProduct doesn’t solve long-term needCustomer research
Power users but many inactive usersUneven user experienceSegment onboarding
Users stall at same stepHidden setup taxReduce configuration friction 

This is decision-support content. Use it to prioritize interventions.


User Adoption Examples

Example 1: SaaS Project Management Tool

Problem: Users sign up but don’t invite team members. Solo usage has low retention.

Intervention: Modify onboarding to emphasize collaboration. Show the value of team features. Add an “Invite Team” step with a template invitation.

Adoption Metric: Percentage of new accounts with 2+ active users within 14 days.

Expected Behavioral Change: Users who invite teammates are 3x more likely to retain.

Example 2: CRM

Problem: Sales reps complete setup but don’t log activities consistently.

Intervention: Add mobile reminders, simplify the activity logging flow, show a dashboard of logged activities vs. team average.

Adoption Metric: Daily active logging rate.

Expected Behavioral Change: Consistent logging becomes a habit.

Example 3: Fintech Application

Problem: Users complete KYC verification but don’t make a first transaction.

Intervention: Offer a small incentive for first transaction, simplify the transaction flow, add contextual guidance at the point of first transaction.

Adoption Metric: Time to first transaction.

Expected Behavioral Change: Users who complete a first transaction are far more likely to become regular users.

Example 4: E-commerce Platform (for Sellers)

Problem: New sellers list one product but don’t list more.

Intervention: Show the correlation between listings and sales. Add a “Complete Your Store” checklist. Offer listing templates.

Adoption Metric: Average listings per seller in first 30 days.

Expected Behavioral Change: Sellers who list 5+ products have significantly higher GMV.

Example 5: B2B Enterprise Software

Problem: Admin users configure the product but end users don’t log in.

Intervention: Create end-user onboarding separate from admin setup. Add in-app guidance for end users. Provide templates that work out-of-the-box.

Adoption Metric: End-user activation rate.

Expected Behavioral Change: Higher end-user adoption drives renewal.


User Adoption Strategy for SaaS Companies

SaaS adoption has unique characteristics: subscription economics, multi-user accounts, and the constant tension between acquisition and retention.

Cover these scenarios:

  • Free trials: Focus on time-to-value. Every day of the trial should drive toward activation.
  • Freemium products: The free tier should demonstrate value while creating natural upgrade triggers.
  • B2B SaaS: Multi-user adoption requires both admin buy-in and end-user engagement.
  • Enterprise SaaS: Longer sales cycles mean onboarding must bridge the gap between purchase and value.
  • Product-led growth: Self-serve adoption requires exceptional onboarding and in-app guidance.
  • Sales-led SaaS: Post-sale adoption requires coordination between sales, customer success, and product.

SaaS User Adoption Funnel

Signup → Activation → First Value → Habit → Feature Adoption → Retention → Expansion

Each stage has distinct metrics and interventions.


User Adoption Strategy for New Product Launches

Adoption starts before launch, not after.

Before Launch:

  • Audience research
  • Positioning and messaging
  • Setting expectations
  • Building anticipation

Launch:

  • Education (webinars, demos, documentation)
  • Onboarding design
  • Activation campaigns
  • Support readiness

Post-Launch:

  • Adoption analytics
  • Feedback collection
  • Feature education
  • Retention optimization

This connects product marketing with user adoption—a bridge most content misses.


User Adoption vs Product Adoption: What’s the Difference?

User AdoptionProduct Adoption
Focuses on usersFocuses on product usage
Behavioral perspectiveProduct/business perspective
Individual/team behaviorOverall product uptake
Measures user actionsMeasures product metrics

The terms are frequently used interchangeably, but understanding the distinction helps clarify which lens you’re using. User adoption is about people. Product adoption is about the product.


Common User Adoption Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake 1: Treating signup as adoption
Signup is the beginning, not the goal.

Mistake 2: Measuring logins instead of value
Logins are activity. Value is outcome.

Mistake 3: Showing every feature during onboarding
Cognitive overload kills adoption.

Mistake 4: Using the same onboarding for everyone
Different users need different paths.

Mistake 5: Relying entirely on email
Email is one channel. In-app guidance is more effective for behavior change.

Mistake 6: Ignoring existing users
Adoption isn’t just for new users. Existing users need feature education too.

Mistake 7: Launching features without an adoption plan
A feature that isn’t adopted might as well not exist.

Mistake 8: Collecting feedback without acting on it
Feedback without action erodes trust.

Mistake 9: Optimizing vanity metrics
Signups and page views don’t pay the bills.

Mistake 10: Never testing onboarding changes
Adoption is an experiment. Test and iterate.


30-Day User Adoption Improvement Plan

This is your implementation roadmap.

Week 1: Research (Days 1–7)

  • Analyze user behavior data
  • Identify drop-off points
  • Interview customers (at least 5)
  • Define or refine your activation event

Week 2: Fix Friction (Days 8–14)

  • Simplify onboarding flow
  • Improve messaging and value proposition
  • Improve empty states
  • Reduce unnecessary steps

Week 3: Create Adoption Campaigns (Days 15–21)

  • Design in-app guidance
  • Create email sequences
  • Build feature education content
  • Set up behavioral segmentation

Week 4: Measure and Experiment (Days 22–30)

  • Compare cohorts (adopters vs. non-adopters)
  • Track adoption rate and time-to-value
  • Run A/B tests on onboarding changes
  • Document learnings

User Adoption Tools

Rather than a promotional list, here are the categories of tools you need:

Product Analytics
For understanding user behavior. Track events, funnels, and retention.

In-App Onboarding
For guiding users. Build tooltips, walkthroughs, checklists, and modals .

Customer Feedback
For discovering friction. Surveys, NPS, and feedback widgets.

Session Recordings
For observing behavior. See where users hesitate, rage-click, or abandon.

CRM / Customer Success Platforms
For tracking customer lifecycle and coordinating interventions.

Experimentation Tools
For testing changes. A/B testing and feature flags.


How AI Is Changing User Adoption

AI is beginning to transform adoption strategies—but it’s not the whole story.

AI-Powered Onboarding
Adaptive onboarding that adjusts based on user behavior and characteristics.

Personalized Product Experiences
AI can recommend features, content, and next steps based on what similar users have done.

Predictive Churn Detection
Identify at-risk users before they churn, based on behavioral signals.

Behavioral Segmentation
AI can identify patterns in user behavior that predict adoption success.

AI Support
Chatbots and AI assistants that answer questions in context.

Adaptive Recommendations
In-app recommendations that surface the most relevant feature or next action.

AI Agents as Users
Some products now have AI agents as users. Adoption for agents means consistent task completion, not emotional engagement .

The key is to use AI to enhance your adoption strategy, not replace the fundamentals: understanding users, reducing friction, and delivering value.


Frequently Asked Questions About User Adoption

What is user adoption?

User adoption is the process of getting users to understand, use, and consistently derive value from a product, service, or feature. Successful adoption occurs when the product becomes part of the user’s regular workflow .

Why is user adoption important?

User adoption drives retention, revenue, and advocacy. Users who adopt stay longer, expand usage, and refer others. Low adoption leads to churn, wasted acquisition spend, and product failure .

What is a user adoption strategy?

A user adoption strategy is a plan that helps users move from awareness to advocacy. It covers onboarding, activation, education, engagement, and measurement .

How do you increase user adoption?

Reduce time to value, personalize onboarding, use contextual guidance, segment users behaviorally, improve feature discoverability, and run experiments. Diagnose the specific friction before prescribing solutions.

How do you calculate user adoption rate?

Adoption Rate = (Adopted Users ÷ Eligible Users) × 100. Define your adoption event clearly and measure consistently .

What is a good user adoption rate?

There is no universal benchmark. It depends on your product, audience, and definition of adoption. Track improvement over time rather than comparing to generic averages.

What is the difference between user adoption and user acquisition?

Acquisition is getting users to sign up. Adoption is getting them to use the product consistently and derive value.

What is the difference between user adoption and user activation?

Activation is a milestone—the first meaningful action. Adoption is the ongoing process of turning activation into habit .

What are the most important user adoption metrics?

Adoption rate, activation rate, time to value, feature adoption rate, DAU/WAU, retention rate, and churn rate .

How can SaaS companies improve user adoption?

Focus on time-to-value, personalize onboarding by segment, use in-app guidance, define activation events, and measure adoption consistently. For multi-user products, ensure both admins and end users are engaged.

What causes low user adoption?

Common causes include unclear value proposition, long time-to-value, complicated onboarding, feature overload, poor discoverability, and lack of personalization .

How long does user adoption take?

It varies. Some products achieve adoption within days; others take weeks or months. The goal is to minimize time-to-value and accelerate habit formation.


Final Takeaway

User adoption isn’t a single onboarding event. It’s the process of helping users repeatedly discover value until your product becomes part of their normal workflow.

The framework is simple:

Understand users → Define value → Reduce friction → Activate → Educate → Engage → Measure → Optimize

Most competitors stop at listing strategies. The opportunity is to diagnose first, prescribe second, and measure always.

Acquisition gets users through the door. Adoption determines whether they stay.

Tags: No tags

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *